The best young adult book tofilm adaptations ranked. Its hard not to feel a little uneasy when a beloved book gets adapted into a major motion picture. I ask this because off the top of my head, i can think of several which makes those on this list decent in comparison. Therefore, there will be a lot of adaptations missing from this list. Features the 10 worst comic book adaptations of all time. Hollywood has a tendency to make bad movies its what keepys michael bay in business. The 15 worst book to film adaptations of all time taste of.
Easily the worst movie on this list, the 2003 live action why. By watching them, we can enjoy the works the way they were meant to be enjoyed. Theres a reason why mockingjay is widely considered the worst book and the two mockingjay movies the worst movies. For a list of films about autism with real or fictional characters, see list of films about autism. Every parent knows that one kids worst fear is another kids no big deal. Nov 12, 2014 the 10 best book to movie adaptations of 2014. And dont think you apprehend the originals with any authority if youve already seen these movies but havent read the books. Starting up the story again made me feel like i was returning to camp. This list ranges from fairly faithful adaptations, to loose reworkings and movies that hardly have anything to do with dracula besides character names. We started our home autism film festival, naturally enough, with barry.
Worst movie adaptations 35 books goodreads share book. This thread just reminded of one of the most pretentious, sleepinducing movies i ever saw, remains of the day, because the book was magnificent and author kazuo ishiguro just won the noble prize for literature. Lawnmower man hobbit and forrest gump movie adaptations completely different from the books. The 1995 film freely adapted from nathaniel hawthornes novel starring demi moore and gary oldman is frequently cited as the worst film adaptation of a classic book. Discussion in obsessions and interests started by gomendosi. Autism spectrum disorders asds are a group of developmental disabilities that can cause significant social, communication and behavioral challenges. The book is pretty beloved for scifi teens but the movie just doesnt hold up for some reason. Mar 14, 2016 that being said, there are certain movie adaptations of books that are, simply put, abominations. Twilight 2008 sometimes the book to movie adaptation is so bad that youre scared to even take a sneak peek into the source material. Sophie, a diligent teenage girl working in her familys hat shop, finds her life thrown into turmoil when she is literally swept off her feet by a. Nov 23, 2010 what makes a film adaptation of a book good or bad.
The book has appeared on a number of best novels lists in the past century, but the movie flew past its novels accolades by becoming only the second film to take home the big five oscars. We here at book riot love to talk about film adaptations of books. The videogame sequence is pure book butchery at its worst. The book made its way to the englishspeaking world after being discovered and translated from the japanese by the novelist david mitchell and his wife, ka yoshida, who have a son with autism. An adaptation of the novel of the same name by jonathan safran foer, it stars. The worst character adaptation from books to movies.
Mark the release of mortal engines with a look at the best and worst ya novelsturned movies. Jan 23, 2020 25 best movie adaptations of classic childrens books. Mar 21, 2016 adaptations of novels that are thematically tied to reading tend not to be as enjoyable as the source material i. I have autism and the lack of authentic autistic voices in. Real stories from people living with autism spectrum disorder. Scratch that sometimes we just love seeing our favorite characters brought to life onscreen, even if its all a glorious mess. The cast is star studded but it just feels so long and boring. I think the only character that can even compete for worst adapation is hermione, she was transformed from a girl with obvious flaws to an supah powahful wonder woman. This japanese movie came out in the late 70s, and the plot was clearly a ripoff of star wars, which had only been released a year or so before. Every single stephen king book, ranked from worst to best. Worst book to movie adaptations 12 book to movie adaptations so bad, the authors deserve letters of apology. Apr 11, 2014 hearing that your favorite book is being turned into a movie can either be the best news in the world, or the worst.
Mar 28, 2016 the 15 worst book to film adaptations of all time. Jump to navigation jump to search this list includes a list of references, but its sources remain unclear because it has insufficient inline citations. Then one day it became a movie and the movie was horrible. I also loved greek mythology as long as i can remember. We guess sometimes reading is more thrilling than watching a movie adaptation. We asked members of the buzzfeed community to tell us what book to movie adaptations. Some film adaptations of books are wonderful, magical narratives, but in other cases, film adaptations stray from their source material and get a little weird. Worst movie adaptations have you read a book and loved it. As a huge gamer as a child, getting a new hardcover book of the series felt better than getting a new game. Write a brief essay on the social, cultural and economic honesty of the book or movie. Worst movie adaptations of all time films that were bad and based off of anything counts, ex. This is a political forum that is nonbiasednonpartisan and treats every persons position on topics equally. Stardust, however, is a mildly entertaining film that all but falls apart when held up to its source.
From the scarlet letter to the nanny diaries, these movies made our list of the worst book to movie adaptations. Its fair enough these adaptations will always be guaranteed large box office takings thanks to the books readers merely showing up to see. Sep 17, 2018 ready player one i loved the eragon and percy jackson books, and yes, the movies were horrible, but i could watch them. Mar 28, 2016 this has made many book lovers around the world very angry, almost to the point that they feel like the movie is an insult to the book and their love of the book. It would have been fun, but they chose the only kids movie that was playing at the time, and it was this one. But needless to say, its one of the most faithful adaptions of a book ive ever seen on film. As the score settles in the lower40s, wrinkle would place somewhere in the middle of this weeks gallery. Best and worst movies based on scififantasy books sez. Jan 12, 20 but for worst movie ever, i am going to go with worst memorable movie ever, which for me would be a message from space. My 8th grade teachers thought it would be fun to take us on a field trip to the movies right after our middle school graduation. The actorwriterdirectors adaptation of steve ericksons 2007 book on 70s. Now i dont know about the best book to movie adaptation frankly because i dont watch that many movies to begin with, but i thought water for elephants was pretty faithful to its original source.
Forget iron man and the dark knight for a minute, and instead be frightened. In addition to the significant and novel aspects of the filmrelated. The worst character adaptation from books to reddit. Here are some of the worst book to film adaptations, in no particular order.
Aug 12, 2014 sometimes the movie is just as good as the book. Worstbest bookbased animated movies phantomstrider. Yes, its exciting to see the story come to life, but we also worry the film wont do the book. There have been plenty of stephen king movies, so there are bound to be some bad films out of the bunch. Top 10 worst movies based on childrens books youtube. We read these books as kids and it was disappointing to see them ruined in these adaptations. Wally bahny examines this question, and asks techrepublic readers to list their picks for the best and worst film adaptations of geek books. Best and worst movies based on scififantasy books sez you. Its a frustrating reality, especially if you know firsthand what its like to live with the condition. The 1995 film freely adapted from nathaniel hawthornes novel starring demi moore and gary oldman is frequently cited as the worst film adaptation of a classic book ever made. Doing nothing to make daredevil stand out from the comic book movie crowd. Cdc is working to find out how many children have asds, discover the risk factors, and raise awareness of the signs. The 10 worst movies based on childrens books yardbarker. The 10 best booktomovie adaptations of 2014 buzzfeed.
Where neil gaimans beloved original is a brisk, crystalline fairytale, matthew vaughns version is flabby and plodding. The 15 worst book to film adaptations of all time page 2. Worst book to movie adaptation cinema, film, script, sci. You have to try and please 1 people who havent read the book and are just looking to have a fun time, as well as 2 people who have read the book and love it, and will wish death upon you and your family and your familys family if you get anything even slightly wrong. Movies being adapted into tv shows, ranked from worst to best idea. For as long as there have been movies, books have served as an inspiration for storylines. Despite some fun performances from andy serkis and paul bettany, the movie was a massive disappointment to fans of the series. Jump to navigation jump to search this list includes a list of references, but its sources remain unclear because it has insufficient. Please help to improve this list by introducing more precise citations. From loud noises to lost pets, choosing movies for young kids can be tricky. Nov 18, 20 we love when a good book gets made into an even better movie. The best and worst movies based on books, according to critics. In order of release, these films made 2014 the year of the book to movie adaptation.
Here is a list of what i consider to be some of the worst booktomovie adaptations. There have been some major duds over the years when it comes to comic book. Hearing that your favorite book is being turned into a movie can either be the best news in the world, or the worst. The top 12 booktomovie adaptions ever made a common complaint among cinema audiences is that the film wasnt as good as the book, and, to be fair, a lot of the time this may very well be the case. I dont mean books about autism, but, rather, novels that include characters who. But imo even anthony hopkins couldnt save this dud, which must go down as one of the worst film adaptations ever. Worst book to movie adaptations score a books total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book.
The best and worst tvto movie adaptations at the box office the best and worst tvto movie adaptations at the box office as baywatch dives into theaters, ew looks back on how other tvto movie. Book because he couldnt bear to see mowgli join the human village. It still could have gone wrong but definitely had that in its favor. Then again, that could be because ive read the book first and when i went to see the movie it flew by pretty quickly.
It tried to add its own jokes on top of the already wacky story, which did not gel well at all. With that in mind, many movie adaptations are well made and convey the same story as the book, with the added visual element to get a whole new experience from the story. Aug 09, 2017 for over two decades, stephen king fans have clamored for a bigscreen adaptation of his epic fantasy saga, the dark tower. All the good parts like someone getting stabbed in the eye are out. Apr 22, 20 5 best and worst movie adaptations from books. Autism advocates embrace the movie, slam critics who disparage the hero. This has made many book lovers around the world very angry, almost to the point that they feel like the movie is an insult to the book and their love of the book. The movie is a slick and cheerless revision of a story beloved for its honesty, and the remake was an unnecessary blight on the moviegoing public and the memory of geisel, who spent his life telling stories so much better than what this film became that im actually glad he wasnt around to see it. Best and worst film adaptations of geek books techrepublic. Three great works of literature well worth avoiding in these film adaptations if you love the books. I second no country for old men as one of the best book to film adaptations.
The trouble with autism in novels the new york times. This isnt an exhaustive list, although i believe ive seen most of the dracula movies i care to see for now, and ill add to the list if i. Feb 12, 2015 why some book tofilm adaptations fail susie rodarme feb 12, 2015 twitter is abuzz right now with news about the cinematic marvel universe bringing spiderman into the fold, which naturally led to some passionate discussion about film adaptations. Dec 31, 2016 hollywood has a tendency to make bad movies its what keepys michael bay in business. Top 10 greatest a christmas carol adaptations youtube. Adding a real layer of nuance to the characters and making it. What are some worst book to film adaptations and why. And dont get me wrong, this is an extremely important book, but it is too short, too. Welcome to autism forums, a friendly forum to discuss aspergers syndrome, autism, high functioning autism and related conditions.
The lawnmower man is the laziest adaptation of them all because its hardly even one, having been named after a stephen king short story with a similar subject matter just for the sake of broadening the films appeal. Though the series is renowned in part for its meta references to kings. If you choose to watch rain man, you are examining the classic or general characteristics of autism and the way raymond portrayed them. The less said about the illadvised film adaptation, the better.
While it is less harsh in some respects, such as in its treatment of nurse ratched, than the book, it still. Jul 19, 2019 three great works of literature well worth avoiding in these film adaptations if you love the books. I can only evaluate an adaptation if ive read the book and seen the movie. Ramsays screenplay dispenses with the format of the book, which was structured as a series of letters from eva to her husband franklin, and with chronology itself. Tv and movies 23 book to movie adaptations that were so bad they inspired rage. This is a list of fictional characters that have been explicitly described within the work in which. Some book toscreen adaptations are bad movies, plain and simple. If you liked this post about book to movie adaptations, you might like these posts too.
Apr 03, 2016 this book is called m is for autism and is written by students from a school especially for girls with asd. The railway children was a genuine breakthrough in childrensbook adaptations. Robert schwentke attempts to cram niffeneggers book into a movie thats less than two hours long. Jun 27, 2016 18 shakespeare film adaptations, ranked from worst to best. Extremely loud and incredibly familiar child mind institute. These two i added, you guys can add the rest because i have not seen any other ones so i cant judge them thanks.
The 15 worst book to film adaptations of all time taste. This is a comprehensive list of the worst book to film adapatations. Altering endings doesnt necessarily make a movie the worst. The worst should be kept to those adaptations which were truly awful, and the question is just how many book to movie adaptations has the article writer seen. Find the best movie for your sensitive kid common sense media. Aug 19, 2016 the princess bride film was helped immensley by the fact that william goldman was a celebrated screenwriter before he wrote the book and then adapted it into a movie. Sadly, these film adaptations just couldnt live up to the bestselling books they were based on. Nov 03, 2017 here are the top 10 best adaptations of a christmas carol. I watched the film version of jurassic park long before i ever read the book. Seusss beloved childrens classic starred mike myers again. For this list, were looking at the best tv and movies based on the famous 1843 novel by charles dickens. Film critics praised the 1995 adaptation for retaining the warmth and wit of the original source material while bringing the words to life. Although the gap between what can go into a comic book and what can go on a movie screen is narrowing, the gap between what alan moore can put in a comic book and what hollywood can put in a movie sadly isnt. In addition to filming near the testing range, truckloads of the red sands were transported back to the studios for interior scenes.
1216 80 657 594 607 1564 1312 598 991 1271 1536 510 905 1177 414 16 501 1585 350 1375 324 695 1288 471 1538 449 1563 435 1253 50 1272 528 167 824 993 342 636 1484 43 706 826 37 1247 640